skarosdrones: (Default)
so I have to repost it here. This time it's all-time.


10. Silence in the Library/Forest of the Dead. Probably the scariest Doctor Who episode out there, with a bunch of creative ideas. Both "shadows that kill you" and "Your entire world is a simulation" would make great episodes on their own (and the second one did about a decade later), and this managed to pull off both at the same time and make them work together

9. The Empty Child/The Doctor Dances. It's scary! It's moving! It has tons of really great lines!

8. Paradise Towers. Unpopular opinion, I know. I just really love it when Doctor Who goes for weird satire, I love how the Doctor gets all the warring factions to work together for a common goal, I love how Pex gets over his toxic masculinity, I love how you can make a bunch of Pokemon Go jokes, I love the camp aesthetic. It's just a really good story.

7. Dark Water/Death in Heaven. I don't know what else to say besides that I find this story absolutely sublime.

6. The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang. Also absolutely sublime, plus I can mention how well it pulled off the disintegration of the universe, how I cried when 11 said goodbye to little Amelia, and how satisfying it was to see Amy and Rory get their happy ending that had the added bonus of being a prelude to even more adventures.

5. In The Forest of the Night. Another unpopular opinion! Here it's because I really love the fantastical atmosphere, plus all the really great interactions between 12 and Clara. Also the kids singing about being Coal Hill's gifted and talented class while the grownups are talking about the world being doomed is one of my all-time favorite moments in the show.

4. Bad Wolf/The Parting of the Ways. I talked about all the reasons this story is so good here.

3. The Curse of Fenric. Pure perfection. After watching this my immediate response was just to watch all the other 7 stories just to see what else this era of the show could do. The answer was "lots of great things" but this is still the best.

2. The Sun Makers. My impression is that this story is well-liked but not particularly well-loved. The reason I put it all the way up here is that it just really pumps me up, and the basic arc of "The Doctor and Leela talk a guy down from suicide and then help him overthrow the system that brought him to that point" is deeply, deeply satisfying. Cordo, incidentally, is ridiculously likable, and it's super great to see his character development. I don't know how much of that is the writing and how much of it is the acting, but either way it works really well. It's also really amusing to me how a story about how great it is to throw your oppressors off of a rooftop aired when the show was getting shit about possibly being inappropriate for children, and how obvious it is that Robert Holmes was really mad about taxes when he wrote this. You can just picture Dennis Healy's kids watching this and wondering why their dad was the bad guy on Doctor Who.

Genesis of the Daleks. This is a story that Does Things to me. The first time I watched it was after a year of feeling basically dead inside and unable to care about anything, and afterward I just couldn't stop thinking or talking about it. It's amazing how well it holds up as a piece of commentary on the dangers of fascism and xenophobia and how they can completely destroy a society from within. Davros and Nyder are both incredible bad guys. The way they're able to get away with everything just by taking advantage of the fact that everyone else has limits of how far they're willing to go is absolutely chilling. I also really like how this explicitly shows how the Daleks came from people who happened to have a really broken society. Other stories treat the Daleks like some Fenrician ancient evil, and it's really cool to see their actual origins as a result of politics. In a weird way, I find this story more depressing than any regeneration or companion exit. This story changes the Daleks from Cyborg Space Nazis to a horrifying tragedy of a society that went wrong in a way it can never come back from. It's truly haunting.

Also, giant clams are good actually. We needed a breather of some sort in all of that
skarosdrones: (Default)
Demons of the Punjab. The story was compelling, it looked great, it put a spotlight on an often forgotten piece of history, and it didn't feel quite like anything the show's done before.

It Takes You Away. I thought the Antizone was cool (or at least my inner 13-year-old did) and it made me cry over a talking frog, which is more or less exactly what I want from this show.

Rosa. Pulled off a somewhat questionable premise for a show like this, started some conversations, and I actually did like that the villain was just some random alt-right coded dipshit.

The Witchfinders. It was... pretty fun. I'm not sure if the beginning deliberately called back to the line in Beast Below about the Doctor not interfering with other peoples or planets unless there's children crying, but kudos if it did.

The Woman Who Fell To Earth. I was excited when I first watched this because Jodie was good.

The Ghost Monument. It was bad in a different way from when Doctor Who was the last time it was bad, and for a moment that can feel similar to being good.

Resolution. Just like Dalek except without everything that made that good and a clunky joke about those damn Millennials and an uncompelling subplot about Ryan's dad.

The Tsuranga Conumdrum. Boring. It pretended it had a big theme about hope and stuff but it didn't. Seeing gifsets and stuff I thought that the Pting would appear near the end, and before that it would seem to everyone like all the problems were caused by some hostile force instead of a little animal just trying to survive, but that would've put a theme in the actual story and we can't have that now can we?

Arachnids in the UK. Also boring. Maybe if they'd given the appearance of Biggest Spider an actual buildup and had had the team have to think to come up with a nicer way to kill the spiders that actually made sense it would've at least been memorable.

The Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos. I had fun watching it, but that was because I was making fun of it and was also drunk.

Kerblam! Man, you're really going to use this show to tell a story about corporate exploitation being good actually. I kinda want to vomit. What happened to not just giving up and making a stand and saying no? I get that not everything I watch is going to have the same political opinions as me, but there's that and then there's like, basic morality.

Profile

skarosdrones: (Default)
Isabel

September 2021

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
2627282930  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Aug. 27th, 2025 12:33 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios